Registry › Compare › Guardrails AI vs PentestAgent

Guardrails AI vs PentestAgent

Guardrails AI leads on trust: 75.1/100 (Grade B) against 57.1/100 (Grade C), a 18.0-point gap. Guardrails AI leads on supply-chain integrity and provenance, and rests on broader evidence; PentestAgent leads on transparency and maintenance.

B Guardrails AI 75.1

Adding guardrails to large language models.

guardrails-ai/guardrails · #277 overall · #6 Security & Guardrails · coverage A (4/5)

Choose Guardrails AI if supply-chain integrity and provenance matter most.

  • +9.0Safety / Integrity: 100% of recent commits signed, against 47%
  • +7.2Identity / Provenance: package provenance attested, against none
  • +6.6Adoption: 7.6k GitHub stars against 3.3k
  • A vs CEvidence coverage: 4 of 5 independent signal types, against 2
C PentestAgent 57.1

PentestAgent is an AI agent framework for black-box security testing, supporting bug bounty, red-team, and penetration testing workflows.

GH05TCREW/pentestagent · #795 overall · #14 Security & Guardrails · coverage C (2/5)

Choose PentestAgent if transparency and maintenance matter most.

  • +2.8Maintenance
  • +0.8Transparency: OSSF Scorecard 6.3 against 5.4

Where they differ

19.2
Safety / IntegrityGuardrails AI +9.0
10.2
18.0
Identity / ProvenanceGuardrails AI +7.2
10.8
13.1
TransparencyPentestAgent +0.8
13.9
11.7
MaintenancePentestAgent +2.8
14.5
15.1
AdoptionGuardrails AI +6.6
8.5
-2.0
Runtime calibrationPentestAgent +1.2
-0.8

Full evidence table

An independent, evidence-based trust comparison of Guardrails AI and PentestAgent, two Security & Guardrails projects in the HVTracker registry. Scores come from public, checkable signals — supply-chain provenance, OSSF Scorecard, maintenance, and adoption — not popularity.

Full evidence

Signal Guardrails AIguardrails-ai/guardrails PentestAgentGH05TCREW/pentestagent
HVTrust score 75.1 57.1
Evidence grade B C
Coverage grade A C
Overall rank #277 #795
Rank in Security & Guardrails #6 #14
GitHub stars 7.6k 3.3k
Last updated 4d ago 13d ago
Build provenance Yes No
OSSF Scorecard 5.4 / 10 6.3 / 10
License Apache-2.0 MIT
Downloads 22k/wk —
Trust dimensions (points earned)
Safety / integrity / 25 19.2 10.2
Identity & provenance / 18 18.0 10.8
Transparency / 17 13.1 13.9
Maintenance / 20 11.7 14.5
Adoption / 20 15.1 8.5
Runtime capability surface (full matrix)
MCP server — Implemented
External providers 3 — Anthropic, Multi-provider (LiteLLM), OpenAI 4 — Anthropic, Multi-provider (LiteLLM), OpenAI, …
Requires API keys Yes Yes
Plugin surface — —
Provenance drift Unknown —
Open in the live compare tool → Guardrails AI profile PentestAgent profile More Security & Guardrails →

How to read this: HVTrust (0–100) weighs supply-chain signals (provenance, OSSF Scorecard, signed commits, open license) alongside real-world adoption, scaled by an evidence-confidence factor. Grade bands: A ≥ 80, B ≥ 65, C ≥ 50, D < 50. Signals refresh daily. Full methodology v4.4 →