Registry › Compare › ASM vs Engram

ASM vs Engram

Both are Grade C and 1.3 points apart, so choose on what you weigh most. ASM leads on supply-chain integrity and transparency; Engram leads on maintenance and adoption.

C ASM 63.3

The universal skill manager for AI coding agents.

luongnv89/asm · #605 overall · #4 Needs review · coverage C (2/5)

Choose ASM if supply-chain integrity and transparency matter most.

  • +2.0Safety / Integrity: OSSF Scorecard 6.3 against 4.5
  • +1.6Transparency: OSSF Scorecard 6.3 against 4.5
C Engram 64.6

Persistent memory system for AI coding agents. Agent-agnostic Go binary with SQLite + FTS5, MCP server, HTTP API, CLI, and TUI.

Gentleman-Programming/engram · #554 overall · #3 Needs review · coverage C (2/5)

Choose Engram if maintenance and adoption matter most.

  • +2.2Adoption: 8.2k GitHub stars against 973
  • +1.0Maintenance

Where they differ

12.4
Safety / IntegrityASM +2.0
10.4
13.9
TransparencyASM +1.6
12.3
19.0
MaintenanceEngram +1.0
20.0
7.2
AdoptionEngram +2.2
9.4
+0.0
Runtime calibrationEngram +1.7
+1.7

1 dimension identical: Identity 10.8 · Full evidence table

An independent, evidence-based trust comparison of ASM and Engram, two Needs review projects in the HVTracker registry. Scores come from public, checkable signals — supply-chain provenance, OSSF Scorecard, maintenance, and adoption — not popularity.

Full evidence

Signal ASMluongnv89/asm EngramGentleman-Programming/engram
HVTrust score 63.3 64.6
Evidence grade C C
Coverage grade C C
Overall rank #605 #554
Rank in Needs review #4 #3
GitHub stars 973 8.2k
Last updated today today
Build provenance No No
OSSF Scorecard 6.3 / 10 4.5 / 10
License MIT MIT
Downloads — —
Trust dimensions (points earned)
Safety / integrity / 25 12.4 10.4
Identity & provenance / 18 10.8 10.8
Transparency / 17 13.9 12.3
Maintenance / 20 19.0 20.0
Adoption / 20 7.2 9.4
Runtime capability surface (full matrix)
MCP server — Implemented
External providers — 1 — Anthropic
Requires API keys No No
Plugin surface — plugins
Provenance drift — —
Open in the live compare tool → ASM profile Engram profile More Needs review →

How to read this: HVTrust (0–100) weighs supply-chain signals (provenance, OSSF Scorecard, signed commits, open license) alongside real-world adoption, scaled by an evidence-confidence factor. Grade bands: A ≥ 80, B ≥ 65, C ≥ 50, D < 50. Signals refresh daily. Full methodology v4.4 →